With Trump’s reinstatement as president, one thing has become clear: JD Vance is the last person any serious thinker should look to for guidance.
Yes, he can recite policy positions with a seeming conviction—he can perform the role of a politician. But nothing he says ever carries insight or illumination.
He is not a thinker.He is not a visionary.He is not an oracle.
He is an empty suit, a hollow vessel, a duck-quacker from Orwell’s 1984—mindlessly repeating the approved lines of the new regime with no original thought behind them.
1. The Vance Illusion: Performance Without Substance
JD Vance presents himself as a serious political figure, but there is nothing serious behind the act.
He will parrot nationalist rhetoric without actually engaging in deep thought about governance.
He will sound populist while aligning himself with the billionaire class.
He will talk tough about foreign policy while offering nothing but empty slogans.
His rise in the Trump administration is not because of his ideas, but because of his loyalty.
Because JD Vance has no guiding philosophy beyond saying whatever keeps him in power.
2. A Man Without Original Thought
Great leaders bring something new to the table.They challenge ideas.They reshape the world with their thinking.
JD Vance does none of this.
Every opinion he holds is dictated by the political winds.
Every statement he makes is a regurgitation of the Trumpist playbook.
Every policy position he takes is designed to please the ruling strongman.
He does not shape the movement—he follows it.He does not push ideas forward—he recites them.
He is a man who wants to be seen as an intellectual but lacks the capacity to be one.
3. The White Bread Politician: Flavorless, Forgettable, and Completely Replaceable
JD Vance is not even a memorable kind of failure.
He is not an Alexander, a Napoleon, or even a Mussolini—figures whose ambition and force of personality shaped history, for better or worse.
He is trashy white bread—lacking even a little toasting for flavor.
Bland and forgettable.
A placeholder, not a leader.
A politician who exists not to inspire, but to maintain the status quo of authoritarian loyalty.
If he were to disappear from politics tomorrow, his absence would not leave a gap—because there was nothing of substance there to begin with.
4. No Oracle, No Visionary, No Future
In a different world, one where ideas matter more than loyalty, JD Vance would be a footnote, a minor bureaucrat in a system too large to notice him.
But in Trump’s America, where empty suits are rewarded for obedience, he gets to play the part of a leader.
Not because he is wise.Not because he is brilliant.Not because he has anything to offer.
But because he is willing to say what he is told to say.
That is not leadership. That is not oratory.That is not the work of a statesman or an oracle.
That is a man who exists to follow, not to lead.
And the sad truth is, when this era is over, JD Vance will be forgotten.
Because history remembers those who shape the world, not those who just repeat the words of others.
Comments